Our local guides attempt to answer that impossible question. Some prefer a late-night greasy slice, others will travel to see a master pizzaiolo at work, others find perfection in the simplicity of a thin crust pie with great ingredients, and some like to keep it close to home. Check out our picks in the above video and let us know if you agree of disagree.
Be sure to subscribe to our You Tube channel here for more videos like this.
Do you have an NYC question you are dying to ask our guides? Leave a comment below and keep an eye out for our answers.